costa de fuegoBENICÀSSIM · 2012
Stories from that summer

Marilyn Manson at Costa de Fuego: a show seen from several sides

3 min · An independent festival keepsake

A black veil concealed much of the stage. That was how Julio Valverde described Marilyn Manson’s opening from the Costa de Fuego crowd. For Radio 3 listeners, the arrival of the headliner on Saturday 21 July 2012 began with a reported image: a partly hidden stage and a journalist trying to explain what was happening.

The station did not have permission to broadcast the show. As with Guns N’ Roses the previous night, it relied on reporting from the grounds. That limitation makes written eyewitness accounts particularly useful companions in reconstructing the performance: they add repertoire, actions and judgements that need not agree.

The character and the songs

Manson arrived with Born Villain as his recent reference point. Metal Symphony places the musical opening at Hey, Cruel World…, following an introduction of Suspiria, and describes an entrance wearing a mask. Clothing and movement helped construct the character alongside the songs.

The same review moves through covers including Personal Jesus and Sweet Dreams, the pulpit of Antichrist Superstar and the arrival of The Beautiful People at the end. These are identifiable points in that witness’s account. They need not become a complete setlist to explain where he found substance in a performance that left him dissatisfied.

The Metal Symphony writer separated his disappointment from what he thought he saw around him. He was highly critical of the show but described a receptive audience. Even a single review could contain two responses: the critic’s own and the reaction he attributed to nearby attendees.

One stage, different impressions

Alfredo Rodríguez offered a more favourable reading in Musicazul, including his surprise at the show. In Música ¡Sí!, Albä Meiga made her own comparisons between the major names and particularly highlighted Nightwish. Read together, the accounts preserve different expectations about what Manson should deliver and what was enough to sustain his performance.

The radio adds a smaller scale. Valverde spoke to a spectator about her interest in the artist; their exchange connected image, clothing and music. The conversation identifies an individual perspective within the anticipation, although the available material cannot securely establish her name. Her answer cannot stand for the entire crowd either.

The programme continued around that appearance. Before Manson, the broadcast placed Katatonia at Black Bikini and Dünedain at Jack Daniel’s Stage. The main stage focused substantial anticipation, but other choices and other listeners remained elsewhere at the festival.

The most faithful reconstruction keeps those perspectives together: the veil described by the reporter, the songs recorded in the press, one critic’s disappointment and another’s favourable surprise. Manson’s appearance does not require a single verdict. It is enough to return to the point when one show began producing different memories.

Sources behind this story